I should have done it
Forse avrei dovuto farlo, ma non ci sono riuscito!
Maybe I should have done it, but I couldn't!
— Le iene (1992)
Non feci che pensare a quella strada buia dove avrei dovuto farlo.
I kept thinking about that dark street where I should have done it.
— La fiamma del peccato (1944)
Immagino che avrei dovuto farlo ieri.
I suppose I should have done it yesterday.
I shouldn't have done that.
Maybe I should have done it.
I shouldn't have done that.