would believe it
Pensi davvero che Tom ci crederebbe?
Do you really think Tom would believe that?
He/She wouldn’t believe it.
Stavo solo scherzando, anche se fosse vero chi diavolo ci crederebbe?
I was just kidding, even if it was true who the hell would believe it?
— Goksung - La presenza del diavolo (2016)
And who would believe it?
— Il Signore degli Anelli - La compagnia dell'anello (2001)
Pensa veramente che Tom ci crederebbe?
Do you really think Tom would believe that?