you should have come
Saresti dovuto venire con noi.
You should have come with us.
Saresti dovuto venire in treno.
You should have come by train.
Non saresti dovuto venire così presto.
You shouldn’t have come so early.
Esatto, saresti dovuto venire da me prima.
That's right, you should have come to me first.
— The Host (2006)
You should have come earlier.